I have it. I've had Buckeye, Direct TV and Dish.
Buckeye and Dish battled for the bottom in terms of equipment issues and service issues, and also in Buckeye's case lack of programming. No way I would go back to either of them.
I have all HD U Verse now since they first threw the switch in this area. Picture clarity is the best of the 4. Programming is the best of the 4. Equipment is the best of the 4. Service is the best of the 4. However, a Direct TV broadcast is seemless from room to room and there is no limit to how much HD you can record at any one time.
There have been times when I've been tempted to go back to Direct TV, until my husband reminds me of the days we spent waiting to get faulty equipment replaced and having no TV but over-the-air stations to watch. We still keep our tower antennae and rotor in good working order and can switch off of U Verse if the need arises. Direct TV equipment is really, really prone to problems.
We have had one epsiode of digital breakup across the spectrum with U Verse which lasted about 20 minutes. We had to have the wireless router replaced once because it wouldn't put out a signal more than two feet away from it. Bad equipment. Couldn't use the wireless lap top unless I was right in front of it. After some time with tech support - and to be completely honest here - some frustration because they wanted to blame my brand new top of the line Toshiba - it was replaced. Our tower computer, which sits right next to the router functioned just fine.
So we stay with U Verse.